diff --git a/src/Mtlstats/Prompt.hs b/src/Mtlstats/Prompt.hs
index d02ccb0..c6c74bc 100644
--- a/src/Mtlstats/Prompt.hs
+++ b/src/Mtlstats/Prompt.hs
@@ -45,6 +45,7 @@ module Mtlstats.Prompt (
   selectPlayerPrompt,
   selectActivePlayerPrompt,
   selectGoaliePrompt,
+  selectActiveGoaliePrompt,
   selectPositionPrompt,
   playerToEditPrompt
 ) where
@@ -316,18 +317,21 @@ selectActivePlayerPrompt
   -> Prompt
 selectActivePlayerPrompt = selectPlayerPromptWith activePlayerSearch
 
--- | Selects a goalie (creating one if necessary)
-selectGoaliePrompt
-  :: String
+-- | Selects a goalie with a specified search criteria (creating the
+-- goalie if necessary)
+selectGoaliePromptWith
+  :: (String -> [Goalie] -> [(Int, Goalie)])
+  -- ^ The search criteria
+  -> String
   -- ^ The prompt string
   -> (Maybe Int -> Action ())
   -- ^ The callback to run (takes the index number of the goalie as
   -- input)
   -> Prompt
-selectGoaliePrompt pStr callback = selectPrompt SelectParams
+selectGoaliePromptWith criteria pStr callback = selectPrompt SelectParams
   { spPrompt       = pStr
   , spSearchHeader = "Goalie select:"
-  , spSearch       = \sStr db -> goalieSearch sStr (db^.dbGoalies)
+  , spSearch       = \sStr db -> criteria sStr (db^.dbGoalies)
   , spSearchExact  = \sStr db -> fst <$> goalieSearchExact sStr (db^.dbGoalies)
   , spElemDesc     = goalieSummary
   , spProcessChar  = capitalizeName
@@ -345,6 +349,26 @@ selectGoaliePrompt pStr callback = selectPrompt SelectParams
     modify $ progMode .~ CreateGoalie cgs
   }
 
+-- | Selects a goalie (creating one if necessary)
+selectGoaliePrompt
+  :: String
+  -- ^ The prompt string
+  -> (Maybe Int -> Action ())
+  -- ^ The callback to run (takes the index number of the goalie as
+  -- input)
+  -> Prompt
+selectGoaliePrompt = selectGoaliePromptWith goalieSearch
+
+-- | Selects an active goalie (creating one if necessary)
+selectActiveGoaliePrompt
+  :: String
+  -- ^ The prompt string
+  -> (Maybe Int -> Action ())
+  -- ^ The callback to run (takes the index number of the goalie as
+  -- input)
+  -> Prompt
+selectActiveGoaliePrompt = selectGoaliePromptWith activeGoalieSearch
+
 -- | Selects (or creates) a player position
 selectPositionPrompt
   :: String
diff --git a/src/Mtlstats/Types.hs b/src/Mtlstats/Types.hs
index 1bee699..b5ad653 100644
--- a/src/Mtlstats/Types.hs
+++ b/src/Mtlstats/Types.hs
@@ -186,6 +186,7 @@ module Mtlstats.Types (
   addPlayerStats,
   -- ** Goalie Helpers
   goalieSearch,
+  activeGoalieSearch,
   goalieSearchExact,
   goalieSummary,
   goalieIsActive,
@@ -1094,6 +1095,23 @@ addPlayerStats s1 s2 = newPlayerStats
   & psAssists .~ s1^.psAssists + s2^.psAssists
   & psPMin    .~ s1^.psPMin + s2^.psPMin
 
+-- | Searches a list of goalies with a search criteria
+goalieSearchWith
+  :: (Goalie -> Bool)
+  -- ^ The search criteria
+  -> String
+  -- ^ The search string
+  -> [Goalie]
+  -- ^ The list to search
+  -> [(Int, Goalie)]
+  -- ^ The search results with their corresponding index numbers
+goalieSearchWith criteria sStr =
+  filter match . zip [0..]
+  where
+    match (_, g)
+      =  map toUpper sStr `isInfixOf` map toUpper (g^.gName)
+      && criteria g
+
 -- | Searches a list of goalies
 goalieSearch
   :: String
@@ -1102,9 +1120,17 @@ goalieSearch
   -- ^ The list to search
   -> [(Int, Goalie)]
   -- ^ The search results with their corresponding index numbers
-goalieSearch sStr =
-  filter match . zip [0..]
-  where match (_, g) = map toUpper sStr `isInfixOf` map toUpper (g^.gName)
+goalieSearch = goalieSearchWith $ const True
+
+-- | Searches a list of goalies for an active goalie
+activeGoalieSearch
+  :: String
+  -- ^ The search string
+  -> [Goalie]
+  -- ^ The list to search
+  -> [(Int, Goalie)]
+  -- ^ The search results with their corresponding index numbers
+activeGoalieSearch = goalieSearchWith (^.gActive)
 
 -- | Searches a list of goalies for an exact match
 goalieSearchExact
diff --git a/test/TypesSpec.hs b/test/TypesSpec.hs
index 1104e51..e6d6340 100644
--- a/test/TypesSpec.hs
+++ b/test/TypesSpec.hs
@@ -81,6 +81,7 @@ spec = describe "Mtlstats.Types" $ do
   psPointsSpec
   addPlayerStatsSpec
   goalieSearchSpec
+  activeGoalieSearchSpec
   goalieSearchExactSpec
   goalieSummarySpec
   goalieIsActiveSpec
@@ -792,6 +793,28 @@ goalieSearchSpec = describe "goalieSearch" $ do
     it "should return Bob" $
       goalieSearch "bob" goalies `shouldBe` [result 1]
 
+activeGoalieSearchSpec :: Spec
+activeGoalieSearchSpec = describe "activeGoalieSearch" $ do
+  let
+    goalies =
+      [ newGoalie 2 "Joe"
+      , newGoalie 3 "Bob"
+      , newGoalie 5 "Steve" & gActive .~ False
+      ]
+    result n = (n, goalies!!n)
+
+  context "partial match" $
+    it "should return Joe" $
+      activeGoalieSearch "e" goalies `shouldBe` [result 0]
+
+  context "no match" $
+    it "should return an empty list" $
+      activeGoalieSearch "x" goalies `shouldBe` []
+
+  context "exact match" $
+    it "should return Bob" $
+      activeGoalieSearch "bob" goalies `shouldBe` [result 1]
+
 goalieSearchExactSpec :: Spec
 goalieSearchExactSpec = describe "goalieSearchExact" $ do
   let